Feedstuffs is part of the Informa Markets Division of Informa PLC

This site is operated by a business or businesses owned by Informa PLC and all copyright resides with them. Informa PLC's registered office is 5 Howick Place, London SW1P 1WG. Registered in England and Wales. Number 8860726.

Pleasant Valley Farms.jpg Pleasant Valley Farms Facebook page

Vermont files lawsuit against dairy farm

Dairy farm contends it filed proper permits and chose legal route to challenge state’s actions.

The Vermont attorney general and Vermont Agency of Agriculture, Food & Markets have filled a complaint against Pleasant Valley Farms of Berkshire LLC and its operators, Mark and Amanda St. Pierre, regarding allegations of permit violations. The lawsuit focuses on violations from actions at the Lumbra Farm located in Berkshire, Vt.  

In the complaint, the state alleges that, in 2017, Pleasant Valley Farms and the St. Pierres expanded an existing barn at the Lumbra Farm without obtaining any necessary permits and approvals and without providing required advanced notice to the Vermont Agency of Agriculture, Food & Markets. The barn is alleged to have increased in size from around 13,000 sq. ft. to approximately 104,000 sq. ft. (roughly 2.4 acres) and from approximately 120 ft. long to 825 ft. long.

In addition to the unpermitted barn expansion, the state alleges that Pleasant Valley Farms and the St. Pierres also built a 10 million gal. manure pit -- capable of accommodating waste for more than 1,500 mature dairy cows -- at the Lumbra Farm without required notice or advanced approval, the attorney general’s statement noted.

In a statement on its Facebook page, the St. Pierre family said they believed they applied for the correct permits for that site. “We feel we were wrongfully denied those permits so opted to appeal, giving us a day in environmental court to explain why,” the statement noted. “We chose to appeal and utilize the judicial system on this matter to stand up for our rights as Vermont dairy farmers. We look forward to our day in court to defend our permitting application.”

In addition to claims relating to the failure to obtain necessary permits and pre-construction approval, the state has alleged violations of Vermont’s required agricultural practices (RAPs) for the farm’s failure to have a nutrient management plan or maintain necessary documents during a 2018 inspection of the Lumbra Farm by the agriculture agency. RAPs are standards to which all types of farms in Vermont must be managed to ensure that agricultural pollution does not reach Vermont’s waters.

The state’s seven-count complaint, which was filed Jan. 2 in the Vermont Superior Court, Franklin Unit, seeks an order requiring Pleasant Valley Farms and the St. Pierres to, among other things: apply for a Large Farm Operation (LFO) permit for the Lumbra Farm, bring the Lumbra Farm into compliance with all required RAPs and LFO rules and pay civil penalties as permitted by law.

The Vermont Agency of Agriculture, Food & Markets has worked with the Vermont Attorney General’s Office in all aspects of this enforcement matter.

“We have a long and proud tradition of farming, agriculture and environmental stewardship in Vermont,” Attorney General T.J. Donovan said. “We need to continue to support our farmers while also protecting water quality and the environment by applying these rules across the board.”

TAGS: Policy Dairy
Hide comments


  • Allowed HTML tags: <em> <strong> <blockquote> <br> <p>

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.