When chemists at the University at Buffalo, The State University of New York (UB), began studying waste disposal at a dairy farm in New York, they thought the farm’s advanced system for processing manure would help remove estrogens and antibiotics from the waste. Instead, the scientists found that the chemicals largely persisted in the treated materials, which are typically reused as fertilizer and animal bedding on the farm.
The manure management process — an advanced anaerobic digestion system — also converted a less harmful form of estrogen in the manure into a form that may pose a greater ecological threat, the researchers said.
Hormones and antibiotics, if not removed from waste, can migrate into the environment and threaten wildlife, while residual antibiotics may encourage the spread of antibiotic resistance.
Even waste treatment systems that are considered state-of-the-art often fail to account for chemicals used routinely in modern society, according to UB researcher Diana Aga, who led the new study. Aga is a professor of chemistry in the UB College of Arts & Sciences and a member of UB RENEW (Research & Education in eNergy, Environment & Water), an institute that addresses complex environmental issues.
"The chemicals we are studying are not exotic," Aga said. "Antibiotics are used to treat sick animals, and the cows on a dairy farm are females, so they produce a lot of estrogens.
"One of the messages of our work is that even anaerobic digestion — an advanced treatment — doesn't totally remove these chemicals, which may pose a danger to the environment. We need to start looking closely at additional treatment techniques to identify better practices," she said.
The research, funded by the New York State Pollution Prevention Institute, was published in two recent papers. The first, on antibiotics, appeared Jan. 22 in the Journal of Environmental Quality. The second, on estrogens, was published Feb. 2 in the journal Science of the Total Environment.
Chemicals on the farm
The farm where Aga and her colleagues conducted their research is a commercial dairy farm with about 2,000 cows.
The facility uses two techniques to treat manure: pasteurization, which uses heat to remove pathogens, and anaerobic digestion, which employs microorganisms to break down and convert biodegradable matter into products that include biogas, liquid fertilizer and solid matter that is repurposed as bedding for the animals.
Aga’s team measured levels of veterinary antibiotics and estrogens in the waste at various points during the treatment process.
The results for antibiotics were mixed: The scientists found that the concentration of tetracyclines was lower in the liquid fertilizer than in the original raw manure. However, the reduction was largely due to the tetracyclines migrating into the solid matter, which had higher levels of the drugs at the end of the treatment than the raw manure had at the start, the team reported.
Macrolides and sulfonamides, two other types of antibiotics the scientists analyzed, were found only at low levels in raw manure and were not detected in the treated manure.
When it came to estrogens, Aga said, “We had hypothesized that the digestion process would remove the hormones, but it didn’t.”
Instead, the total concentration of estrogens remained relatively steady.
In addition, the treatment process appeared to convert a less harmful form of estrogen into one with greater potential for disrupting the function of animals’ endocrine systems, which produce hormones that regulate growth, reproduction and other biological functions. Prior to anaerobic digestion, 65% of the estrogens in the manure were in a form with lower endocrine-disrupting potential. After the process, 72% of the estrogens were in a form with higher endocrine-disrupting potential.
Identifying best practices
Aga noted that each farm has a unique system for processing waste, so it’s possible that a different anaerobic digestion technique or a completely different treatment method could yield better results. The next step in the research will be to explore various treatment techniques to identify best practices.
“When it comes to manure treatment, there are a lot of variables to explore: how much time the manure is treated for during anaerobic digestion, whether the manure is mixed with food waste or not or whether the digested product is further composted or treated by other means. For farms using long-term storage, it may also matter if the lagoons are covered up or not,” Aga said. “We need to do more research to find out.”